Trade-in with Game Day Legends!
Trades are just part of the game and we've got you covered!
Trade in your previously loved sports memorabilia toward something new to enjoy!
Our Trade-in program was created for memorabilia enthusiasts who are looking to build up their Legendary Collections! Whether you're looking to save and build up credit towards high-end crown jewels, or just want to cash in your current items for another item available in our inventory, we have you covered!
- Do you have your eye on some memorabilia that you'd like to add to your collection without breaking the bank?
- Do you enjoy participating in Memorabilia Breaks but don't always love the items that you win?
- Need a change of scenery and want to trade in for today's hottest memorabilia?
Accepted Items:
- Autographed Sports Memorabilia
- Graded/Encapsulated Sports Cards, Autographed Cards w/ a minimum $20+ Value
- Game-Used Memorabilia with proper documentation
- Autographed Entertainment Memorabilia with proper Certificate of Authenticity, Graded Comic Books, Graded Coins
We are happy to evaluate your Memorabilia items for Trade Credit with the following guidelines:
- Item must be damage-free with no cosmetic issues to the item or autograph
- Item must have certificate of authenticity from one of the leading authentication companies (Fanatics, Beckett, PSA, JSA, Schwartz, Mill Creek, Dave and Adams, Upperdeck, Steiner, Tri-Star. Other reputable companies will be reviewed as well)
- Item should be the players current team. If your item is signed by a retired player, it should be the team they played with for the majority of their career
If you accept our Trade-in Credit offer, you are responsible for safely packaging your items and shipping to us. Once received, our team will inspect all items to ensure they are damage-free and in great condition. Upon inspection, if there's damage/flaws with the autograph on your item, we reserve the right to cancel our offer. You will be responsible to cover the return shipping of your items back to you.
Once your trade-in order has been processed, you will be able to use your Trade-in Credit immediately! Shop our online store to view items you can put your trade credit towards. Or if you want to stash you Store Credit and build it up towards a high-end piece, you can! Trade Credit never expires, watch your credit balance stack up with each trade and get yourself one step closer to that signed piece you have your eye on!
Questions about the trade-in process?
Please contact us by filling out the form below.How to Request a Trade-In:
Fill out the form on this page to let us know what you would like to trade-in. We will respond to you with instructions on how to submit images. To have your item reviewed for trade-in approval, please send us photos of your item(s). Photos must include a clear photo of the signature on the item and a clear photo of the item's COA hologram (so that we can lookup the COA # in the online database to confirm authenticity). Once your trade item(s) has been reviewed and is approved, we will tell you the amount of trade-in credit you will receive to spend on our website. If you accept the trade-in credit offer, you will be given shipping instructions for where to send your item and once we receive the item, we will issue you a code to use at checkout for your new item.How much will I get for my item?
Once we determine how much your item is worth, we will let you know the minimum you can expect to receive for it.Interested? Questions about the trade-in process?
Please contact us by filling out the form below.